New Jersey

New Jersey: Court Upholds Reinstatement of Employee Discharged After Positive Cannabis Test

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in NJ

EFFECTIVE

SEP 21, 2026

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • A federal district court upheld an arbitrator’s reinstatement of an employee discharged after a second positive cannabis test under the employer’s two-strike policy.
  • The court emphasized the absence of evidence of on-duty use or impairment beyond a reported marijuana odor and the positive test.

Discussion

On September 21, 2026, in County Concrete Corporation v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters Local 863, the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey upheld an arbitrator’s award reinstating an employee who was discharged after testing positive for cannabis. As the basis for termination, the employer relied on a reported marijuana odor and the employee’s second positive test, but the arbitrator found that the employer had not established workplace cannabis use, possession, or impairment. The court declined to overturn that determination under the deferential standard applicable to labor arbitration awards.

 

New Jersey’s Cannabis Regulatory, Enforcement Assistance, and Marketplace Modernization Act (CREAMMA) prohibits employers from taking adverse employment action solely because an employee tests positive for cannabinoid metabolites. The law permits testing in circumstances including reasonable suspicion of on-duty cannabis use, observable signs of intoxication, and certain work-related accidents. The distinction matters because a positive test does not, by itself, establish that an employee used cannabis at work or was impaired while working.

 

In this case, during a lunch break, the employee in question drove his personal vehicle past a supervisor and coworker on company property. Both reported detecting a strong marijuana odor from the vehicle. The employer directed the employee to undergo testing, which returned a positive result. Because the employee had previously tested positive, the company terminated him under its two-strike policy.

 

The employee’s union challenged the termination through arbitration. The arbitrator ordered reinstatement with full back pay, seniority, and benefits, finding insufficient evidence that the employee used or possessed cannabis at work or was impaired. The employer then asked the federal court to vacate the award, arguing that the arbitrator disregarded CREAMMA and exceeded her authority under the collective bargaining agreement.

 

The court explained that judicial review of labor arbitration awards is limited. A court does not simply reconsider the underlying dispute or substitute its judgment for the arbitrator’s, even when an employer alleges errors of law or fact. Within this framework, the court found that the arbitrator had not manifestly disregarded CREAMMA or exceeded her contractual authority.

 

The court explained that marijuana odor, standing alone, showed only that cannabis may have been present at some point, not that the employee used it while performing his duties or was impaired on company property. Additionally, the court emphasized the absence of other evidence, finding that there was no testimony that the employee slurred his speech, had glassy eyes, performed poorly, or otherwise appeared impaired. The employer also allowed him to finish his shift without any reported impairment and did not document the reported odor until more than a week later. These facts departed from nonbinding best practices issued by the New Jersey Cannabis Regulatory Commission, which the arbitrator considered when evaluating the evidence.

 

The decision does not establish that every cannabis-related termination requires the same evidence or that the Commission’s best practices are independently binding requirements. It does illustrate the risk of relying on a positive test and odor without additional evidence connecting the concern to workplace conduct. Importantly, a policy allowing termination after a specified number of positive tests does not eliminate the need to comply with CREAMMA.

 

Action Items

  1. Review cannabis testing and disciplinary policies, including automatic termination provisions, for compliance.
  2. Establish procedures for promptly documenting specific observations supporting suspected on-duty cannabis use or impairment.
  3. Have appropriate personnel trained on drug testing requirements.
  4. Consult with legal counsel before taking adverse action as the result of a positive employee test.

 

 

New Jersey: Proposal to Drop Pay Range Cap

On October 19, 2026, the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development (NJDOL) proposed revising its still-pending September 2025 pay transparency regulations to remove a numerical cap on posted pay ranges. The original proposal would have limited the difference between a range’s maximum and minimum to 60 percent of the minimum. The October notice proposes deleting that provision, including its calculation method and exceptions, while leaving the remaining proposed requirements unchanged. Neither the original regulations nor the proposed revision has been finalized, so the cap is not an existing obligation. New Jersey’s pay transparency statute, effective June 1, 2025, remains in effect, including pay and benefits disclosures for covered postings and reasonable efforts to notify affected employees of promotional opportunities. Employers should continue complying with the statute and monitor the rulemaking for final requirements and an effective date. Written comments on the proposed revision are due December 18, 2026.

 

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

New York

New York: New Guidance for Trapped at Work Act

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in NY

EFFECTIVE

As Indicated

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • The Trapped at Work Act is a broad ban with narrow exceptions, and it applies only to new or changed agreements.
  • Voluntary agreements, non-employer arrangements, and legally authorized agreements are outside the Act.
  • Educational repayment is allowed only for “transferable credentials.”

Discussion

The New York State Department of Labor (NYSDOL) issued guidance for the Trapped at Work Act (Act) to clarify several outstanding issues before the law goes into effect on December 19, 2026.

As background, the Act broadly prohibits promissory notes or other agreements that require workers to repay certain amounts if they resign before completing a specified minimum period of employment. Subject to statutory conditions and limitations, the Act permits the following arrangements:

  • Agreements to reimburse the employer for “the cost of tuition, fees, and required educational materials for a transferable credential” under the statute’s five conditions;
  • Agreements to pay for “any property the employer has sold or leased to the employee”;
  • Agreements requiring repayment of “a financial bonus, relocation assistance, or other non-educational incentive or other payment or benefit that is not tied to specific job performance,” subject to limits on terminations and misrepresentation;
  • Agreements requiring educational personnel to comply with sabbatical leave terms; and
  • Agreements entered into as part of a collective bargaining agreement.

 

NYSDOL’s new guidance provides the following clarifications regarding the Act’s coverage and exceptions:

Effective Date. The Act applies to new agreements, or new or amended terms in existing agreements, entered into on or after December 19, 2026.

Agreements Affected. The Act applies to any agreement, or term in an agreement, that requires an employee to pay their employer (or employer’s agent or assignee) a sum of money if the employment relationship terminates before a specific period. There is no express requirement that the agreement be in writing.

Exceptions. The Act does not apply to:

 

  • Agreements that are voluntary and separate from maintaining or accepting employment, meaning that the employee could continue with employment without agreeing to the terms (i.e., the agreement is not a condition of employment).
  • Arrangements that are not between an employer (or its agent or assignee) and an employee (e.g., a loan forgiveness program that depends on maintaining employment but is between a lender and borrower).
  • Agreements that are expressly allowed or required under statute or common law (e.g., lawful wage advances under Labor Law 193 and NYCRR 195-5.2 or lawful advance payments under Insurance Law 4228).

 

Educational Repayment. For purposes of permissible educational expense repayment, a transferable credential is any degree, diploma, license, certificate, or documented evidence of skill proficiency or course completion that:

 

  • Employers widely recognize in a relevant industry as a qualification for employment (independent of the employer’s specific business practices);
  • Provides skills or qualifications that demonstrably enhance the employee’s employability with other employers in the relevant industry;
  • Is NOT employer-specific or non-transferable training; and
  • Is NOT mandated safety and compliance training.

 

Action Items

  1. Review repayment agreements that are conditioned on employment with legal counsel.

 

 

New York: Nonsexual, Gender-Based Conduct Can Constitute Sexual Harassment

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in NY

EFFECTIVE

OCT 20, 2026

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • Demeaning, gender-based conduct can qualify as sexual harassment even with no sexual content.
  • The ruling is fact-specific, and a prompt response to sexual harassment complaints still matters.

Discussion

In Elshabrowy v. Ali Awad Law, P.C., the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York ruled allegations of nonsexual, gender-based hostile treatment can constitute sexual harassment under the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and the New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL). Here, a Muslim woman of Arab descent, who worked remotely for a personal injury law firm, alleged hostile treatment after she began wearing a hijab. Among her allegations were a company executive showing discomfort toward her; stalling her projects; interfering with her administrative access; yelling at her; and calling her and her team “incompetent.” When she complained to the CEO, she was told she was “emotional” and to accept typical male “aggressive” behavior from the executive. She was subsequently also told she was embarrassing herself and was “not the most intelligent person in the room.” She was also excluded from carpools to Friday prayers that were routinely offered to Muslim men. She filed an HR complaint which was never investigated and was terminated a few months later. She then filed claims for gender and religious discrimination under the NYCHRL and NYSHRL.

 

In reaching its ruling, the court reviewed guidance from the New York City Commission on Human Rights which indicates that conduct does not need to be sexual in nature to constitute sexual harassment. Such harassment can consist of unwelcome verbal or physical behavior based on a person’s gender. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals has also found that a hostile work environment claim does not require sex-specific conduct or conduct motivated by sexual desire. Here, the conduct the plaintiff encountered was unwelcome gender-based conduct: (1) sex-stereotyping by calling her emotional; (2) verbal abuse directed at her but not at male colleagues; (3) evidence of another hijab-wearing woman who resigned; and (4) termination after filing an HR complaint.

 

The court emphasized that its ruling was limited to the facts of this case and that not every allegation of gender-based mistreatment constitutes sexual harassment. Here, the verbal conduct, considered collectively, supported that finding. Employers should promptly consult legal counsel when evaluating and responding to sexual harassment allegations.

 

Action Items

  1. Promptly investigate claims of sexual harassment.
  2. Have appropriate personnel trained on how to respond to complaints of harassment, discrimination, and retaliation.
  3. Consult with legal counsel prior to taking adverse action against an employee who filed a complaint.

 

 

New York, NY: Final Rules Adopted Under the Fair Chance Act

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in New York, NY

EFFECTIVE

OCT 30, 2026

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • Employers cannot inquire into or investigate an applicant’s criminal history before making a conditional offer, including through targeted online searches.
  • Employers must consider required factors when evaluating pre-employment conviction history.
  • Before taking adverse action based on criminal history, employers must provide written disclosures and an opportunity to respond.

Discussion

The New York City Commission on Human Rights adopted final rules implementing the Fair Chance Act (Act), which prohibits employers from inquiring about an applicant’s criminal history before making a conditional job offer. Before taking adverse action based on an applicant’s or employee’s criminal history, employers must provide a written individualized assessment and an opportunity to respond. Key provisions of the rules are summarized below.

 

Fair Chance Employment Factors for Pre-Employment Conviction Histories. Employers must consider the following factors when evaluating an applicant’s or employee’s pre-employment conviction history:

 

  • New York’s public policy encouraging the licensure and employment of people with criminal records;
  • The specific duties and responsibilities necessarily related to the prospective job;
  • The bearing, if any, of the conviction history on the applicant’s or employee’s fitness or ability to perform one or more of the job’s duties or responsibilities;
  • The time elapsed since the criminal offense that led to the conviction, rather than the time since arrest or conviction;
  • The applicant’s or employee’s age when the criminal offense occurred;
  • The seriousness of the applicant’s or employee’s conviction;
  • Any information provided by or on behalf of the applicant or employee regarding rehabilitation and good conduct; and
  • The employer’s legitimate interest in protecting property and the safety and welfare of specific individuals or the general public.

 

Criminal History Defined. “Criminal history” is defined to include records of an individual’s convictions, unsealed violations, non-convictions, and currently pending criminal cases.

Expanded Prohibition. The rules also identify the following actions as investigations into an applicant’s criminal history: (1) the use of publicly available records or the Internet for the purpose of learning about an applicant’s criminal history; (2) searching for terms such as “arrest,” “mugshot,” “warrant,” “criminal,” “conviction,” “jail,” or “prison” in connection with an applicant; or (3) searching websites that purport to provide information regarding arrests, warrants, convictions, or incarceration information for the purpose of obtaining criminal history information about an applicant.

 

Inadvertent Disclosure. Inadvertent discovery by an employer or a disclosure by an applicant of criminal history prior to a conditional offer of employment does not automatically create employer liability. However, the employer may not use that information to further investigate the applicant’s criminal history before making a conditional offer or to determine whether to make an offer.

 

Adverse Action. If an employer wishes to revoke the conditional offer of employment or take an adverse employment action based on criminal history, the employer must first: (1) provide the applicant or employee with a written copy of any inquiry made to collect criminal history information; (2) provide a written copy of the Fair Chance Employment Analysis; (3) inform the individual that they will have a reasonable response period of at least five business days; and (4) consider any additional information the individual provides during that period.

 

Employers should review the rules with legal counsel and assess whether their hiring and criminal history review procedures need updating.

 

Action Items

  1. Review and update criminal history inquiry and adverse action procedures with legal counsel.
  2. Have appropriate personnel trained on hiring and background screening requirements.

Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

North Carolina

Discussion

North Carolina: Retaliatory Employment Discrimination Act Complaint Process Modified

As of October 4, 2026, HB 258 specifies the information that must be included in a complaint filed with the Commissioner of Labor under the Retaliatory Employment Discrimination Act. If the complaint is filed by anyone other than the complainant or their attorney, the filer must submit a written authorization from the complainant allowing the person to file the complaint on their behalf. A complainant has 30 days to correct any inconsistencies upon notification. Within seven days of receipt of the complaint, the respondent may submit a position statement outlining affirmative defenses. Any extraneous materials submitted along with the complaint shall not be considered in the investigation and shall be destroyed. While these changes modify the complaint process, they do not alter employers’ obligations under the Act’s anti-retaliation provisions.


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

Ohio

Discussion

Ohio: Statewide Minimum Wage Increase

Effective January 1, 2027, Ohio’s minimum wage will increase to $11.40 per hour for employers with annual gross receipts exceeding $420,000 in 2026. The minimum cash wage for tipped employees will increase to $5.70 per hour, provided wages plus tips equal at least the full minimum wage. Employers at or below the receipts threshold, and employees under age 16, remain subject to the $7.25 federal minimum wage. Employers should update payroll and any affected overtime calculations before January 1.

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

Pennsylvania

Allegheny County, PA: New Paid Parental Leave and Expanded Paid Sick Leave

APPLIES TO

As Indicated

EFFECTIVE

APR 20, 2027

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • Employers must provide eligible employees with 12 weeks of paid parental leave in an applicable 12-month period.
  • Employers with 15 or more employees must provide up to 72 hours of paid sick leave per year, accrued at the rate of one hour for every 30 hours worked.
  • Employers with fewer than 15 employees must provide up to 48 hours of paid sick leave per year.

Discussion

On October 22, 2026, Allegheny County amended the Rules and Regulations for Paid Sick and Parental Leave, adding employer-funded parental leave benefits and expanding existing paid sick leave benefits to match Pittsburgh’s requirements. The changes take effect 180 days after passage, and employers have another 180 days to put them in place.

 

New Paid Parental Leave. Eligible workers receive 12 weeks of paid leave after a birth, stillbirth, adoption, or permanent foster placement. They can take it any time in the applicable 12-month period. Spouses or domestic partners at the same employer can both take leave, even at the same time. The law applies to workers employed at least 180 days in a row. Part-time workers must also have worked at least 625 hours in that time. Employees receive their regular base pay plus benefits, up to $4,200 a week. Part-time workers’ pay is based on their average weekly hours over the past six months.

 

An employee must give the employer documents (such as a birth certificate or adoption papers) and a leave schedule to initiate the leave process. The employer has 10 business days to determine eligibility for leave. Any approval must be given in writing and confirm the amount of benefit to be received. If the employer denies eligibility or does not answer, the employee can complain to a county agency, which has three business days to rule. Employees receive job protection while on leave and must be returned to their job or an equivalent position when they return. Benefits continue while on leave and retaliation is prohibited.

 

Employers must:

 

  • Give employees written notice of their rights when hired and every year after.
  • Confirm each leave request in writing.
  • Maintain applicable records for two years.
  • Notify the employee in writing prior to disclosure when required to disclose information received from an employee.
  • File a yearly certification with the county saying they have complied.

 

Employees must give 30 days’ notice when the need for leave is known ahead of time; otherwise, notice must be provided as soon as practicable. Parental leave runs concurrently with federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) leave. Employers may use a private insurance plan if it offers at least the same benefits.

 

Changes to Paid Sick Leave. Employees will now earn one hour of sick time for every 30 hours worked, up from one for every 35 hours. How much an employee can accrue depends on employer size:

 

  • Employers with 15 or more workers: Employees may accrue up to 72 hours a year, increased from 40. This also replaces the previous cutoff of 26 workers.
  • Employers with fewer than 15 workers: Employees may accrue up to 48 hours a year.

 

Many existing rules stay the same. New workers can start using sick time on their 90th day. Unused sick time carries over to the next year unless the full amount is frontloaded at the beginning of the year. Employers are not required to pay out unused sick leave balances upon termination. Employers can ask for a doctor’s note only for absences of three or more days in a row. However, fines for willful violations are rising to as much as $100 per day, per violation. Before, it was $100 per offense.

 

While the rules contemplate that an employer may have a paid time off policy that encompasses and meets the requirements of paid sick leave, they also say that employers shall provide “designated paid sick leave” notwithstanding the PTO policy. This seems to indicate that the amount of sick leave contemplated by a PTO policy should be specifically and separately stated.

 

Action Items

  1. Review the amended full rules and regulations here.
  2. Have leave policies updated for compliance.
  3. Implement leave request and eligibility review processes for compliance.
  4. Provide required notices on hire and annually.
  5. Certify compliance with the County annually.
  6. Have appropriate personnel trained on the updated leave requirements.

 

 

Pennsylvania: One Statute of Limitations for Both PMWA and WPCL

On October 21, 2026, in Commonwealth Department of Labor and Industry v. Accuserv Pharmacy, the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court said that the statute of limitations for the Pennsylvania Minimum Wage Act (PMWA) and Wage Payment and Collection Law (WPCL) is three years for both. The WPCL specifies a three-year limitation; the PMWA has none stated. The PMWA has a three-year record retention requirement but has historically been attributed a general six-year limitation. The court resolved the inconsistency by reading the two laws together as serving the same purpose and in light of PMWA’s mandate to preserve pay records for three years. Allowing a claim period longer than the required record retention period would make the evidence preservation requirement irrelevant.

 

Pennsylvania: Wages Must Be Unpaid for a WPCL Claim to Proceed

On October 29, 2026, in Aita v. NCB Management Services, Inc., the Pennsylvania Supreme Court said that an employee cannot bring a claim under the Wage Payment and Collection Law (WPCL) unless they have unpaid wages at the time suit is filed. Similarly, liquidated damages can only be awarded for owed wages, and there is no cause of action solely for liquidated damages. Here, the employee was paid all wages plus interest 16 months before filing suit. Therefore, the standalone claim for liquidated damages was not allowed to proceed.

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

Texas

Texas: Properly Drafted Forfeiture Clauses Are Not Noncompetes

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in TX

EFFECTIVE

AUG 6, 2026

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • The court upheld a provision conditioning an additional, unvested payment on a departing physician practicing outside a specified geographic area.
  • Because the provision required forfeiture of the payment rather than prohibiting competition, the court found it was not subject to the Texas Covenants Not to Compete Act.

Discussion

In Healing Hearts Clinic v. Ramineni, the Texas Court of Appeals ruled that a shareholder agreement paying a departing physician an extra 50% of his accounts receivable only if he practiced outside a 20-mile radius was not a covenant not to compete. Here, the defendant physician had a shareholder agreement with the above-referenced clause for departing physicians. He also had a separate employment agreement with a two-year, 20-mile noncompete with a $100,000 buyout. When he resigned, he paid the buyout and opened a cardiology practice across the street from the plaintiff. The plaintiff did not stop him from practicing but refused to pay the 50% of his accounts receivable in accordance with the shareholder agreement.

 

In reaching its ruling, the court found that the shareholder agreement did not restrain the defendant’s ability to compete as governed by the Texas Covenants Not to Compete Act. Instead, it required him to forfeit an unearned payment if he chose to do so. This additional, unvested benefit does not have to satisfy the statutory requirements for a noncompete. The court opined that employees who breach such agreements only forfeit the benefit and are not prohibited from working. Therefore, employers can use forfeiture clauses alongside compliant noncompetes.

 

Action Items

  1. Review forfeiture and noncompetition clauses with legal counsel.

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

Washington

Discussion

Washington: Noncompete Salary Threshold Increases Ahead of Noncompete Ban

Effective January 1, 2027, Washington’s annual earnings thresholds for enforcing noncompete agreements will increase to $131,326.59 for employees and $328,316.49 for independent contractors. Importantly, these thresholds govern the enforceability of noncompete agreements, not an individual’s classification as an exempt employee or independent contractor. The thresholds will apply only through June 30, 2027, because Washington’s statewide noncompete ban will make such agreements unenforceable beginning July 1, regardless of earnings. Employers should review existing agreements with legal counsel and prepare for the upcoming ban.

 

Washington: Tukwila, Renton, and Burien Announce Minimum Wage Increases

Additional Washington localities, including Tukwila, Renton, and Burien, have announced minimum wage increases effective January 1, 2027. Tukwila’s minimum wage will increase to $22.45 per hour. Renton’s minimum wage will increase to $22.28 per hour for employers with 15 or more employees (employers with fewer than 15 employees are covered by the statewide minimum wage). Burien’s minimum wage will increase to $20.49 per hour for employers with 15 or fewer employees and $22.49 per hour for employers with 16 or more employees. Employers should update hourly pay rates and any affected overtime calculations before January 1.

 

Washington: Proposed Updates to Construction PPE Rule

On October 6, 2026, Washington’s Division of Occupational Safety and Health (DOSH) proposed updating its construction personal protective equipment (PPE) rules to expressly require employers to ensure PPE properly fits each affected employee. The change would align Washington’s rule with federal OSHA’s construction PPE requirement, which took effect in January 2025. The proposal would also clarify employer responsibility for providing certain PPE and make minor housekeeping revisions. It does not define “properly fits” or establish specific fit criteria. Public comments are due November 23, 2026, and DOSH has identified March 2, 2027, as its intended adoption date, although it is not a confirmed effective date. Construction employers should review PPE selection and sizing practices and monitor the rulemaking for final requirements and compliance dates.

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase

Wisconsin

Wisconsin: Court Clarifies Employer’s Duty to Rehire Injured Workers

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in WI

EFFECTIVE

OCT 6, 2026

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • The Wisconsin Court of Appeals clarified employees’ initial burden when claiming that an employer unreasonably refused to rehire them following a compensable workplace injury.
  • Under the clarified standard, an employee does not need to show that their workplace injury caused the refusal to rehire or that they formally applied for rehire.

Discussion

In Bartelt Custom Automotive, Inc. v. LIRC, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals clarified employees’ initial burden when claiming that an employer unreasonably refused to rehire them following a compensable workplace injury. To establish an initial case under Wisconsin’s Worker’s Compensation Act, an employee must show that they were employed by the employer, sustained a workplace injury, and were subsequently denied rehire. The employee does not need to establish that the injury caused the employer’s decision or that they formally applied for rehire. The employer may then establish that it had a reasonable basis for not rehiring the employee.

 

This case involved a welder who was released to return to work without restrictions after a workplace injury. The employer had filled his welding position and told him that work had slowed down and he was being laid off. However, a press brake operator position remained open. The employee had experience performing that work but had declined the position before being hired because he preferred other duties.

 

The employer argued that the employee’s earlier rejection of the position, combined with his failure to express renewed interest, provided a reasonable basis for not offering it. The court disagreed finding that, because the employer knew the employee was qualified for the open position, it had a duty to offer him the role despite his earlier rejection. The employee had already communicated his ability and willingness to return to work and was not required to ask about openings he did not know existed.

 

The decision underscores that an employer’s review should not end when an injured employee’s former position is unavailable. Employers should consider other open positions the employee can perform rather than assume that a prior rejection still reflects the employee’s preferences. Communicating available opportunities and documenting offers and responses can help support the employer’s handling of the return-to-work process.

 

Action Items

  1. Review return-to-work procedures for employees with work-related injuries.
  2. Establish a process to document available positions, qualification assessments, job offers, employee responses, and the reason for any decision not to rehire an injured employee.
  3. Consult with legal counsel before declining to rehire an injured employee.

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase