Wisconsin

Wisconsin: Court Clarifies Employer’s Duty to Rehire Injured Workers

APPLIES TO

All Employers with Employees in WI

EFFECTIVE

OCT 6, 2026

QUESTIONS?

Contact HR On-Call

(888) 378-2456

 

Quick Look

  • The Wisconsin Court of Appeals clarified employees’ initial burden when claiming that an employer unreasonably refused to rehire them following a compensable workplace injury.
  • Under the clarified standard, an employee does not need to show that their workplace injury caused the refusal to rehire or that they formally applied for rehire.

Discussion

In Bartelt Custom Automotive, Inc. v. LIRC, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals clarified employees’ initial burden when claiming that an employer unreasonably refused to rehire them following a compensable workplace injury. To establish an initial case under Wisconsin’s Worker’s Compensation Act, an employee must show that they were employed by the employer, sustained a workplace injury, and were subsequently denied rehire. The employee does not need to establish that the injury caused the employer’s decision or that they formally applied for rehire. The employer may then establish that it had a reasonable basis for not rehiring the employee.

 

This case involved a welder who was released to return to work without restrictions after a workplace injury. The employer had filled his welding position and told him that work had slowed down and he was being laid off. However, a press brake operator position remained open. The employee had experience performing that work but had declined the position before being hired because he preferred other duties.

 

The employer argued that the employee’s earlier rejection of the position, combined with his failure to express renewed interest, provided a reasonable basis for not offering it. The court disagreed finding that, because the employer knew the employee was qualified for the open position, it had a duty to offer him the role despite his earlier rejection. The employee had already communicated his ability and willingness to return to work and was not required to ask about openings he did not know existed.

 

The decision underscores that an employer’s review should not end when an injured employee’s former position is unavailable. Employers should consider other open positions the employee can perform rather than assume that a prior rejection still reflects the employee’s preferences. Communicating available opportunities and documenting offers and responses can help support the employer’s handling of the return-to-work process.

 

Action Items

  1. Review return-to-work procedures for employees with work-related injuries.
  2. Establish a process to document available positions, qualification assessments, job offers, employee responses, and the reason for any decision not to rehire an injured employee.
  3. Consult with legal counsel before declining to rehire an injured employee.

 


Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase