California
California: Fair Chance Act Individualized Assessments Cannot be Second-Guessed
|
APPLIES TO All Employers with Employees in CA |
EFFECTIVE SEP 18, 2026 |
QUESTIONS? Contact HR On-Call |
Quick Look
|
Discussion
In McInerney v. Regents of the University of California, a California Court of Appeal said that courts and juries cannot second-guess an employer’s individualized assessment under the California Fair Chance Act. Specifically, the Fair Chance Act requires employers to conduct an individualized assessment of the nature of the offense, how much time has passed, and the nature of the job, plus give notice and a chance to respond before rescinding an offer.
Here, a former UCLA student was turned down for a campus job because of his criminal record. After he received a conditional offer in 2021 for an office assistant job, a public-facing role that required a background check, the screening revealed four drug convictions from 2005 to 2007. UCLA sent him a letter giving him five business days to provide evidence of rehabilitation. Instead of providing any, he sent HR staff angry emails, using profanity and comparing UCLA to “North Korea” and the “Inquisition.” UCLA rejected him after only two days, not the full five that California’s Fair Chance Act requires. The decision-maker testified that the main reason was that the plaintiff gave no evidence of rehabilitation in response to the letter.
The court noted that the Fair Chance Act is a procedural law employers must follow when conducting background checks; it does not contemplate second-guessing employment decisions. It also does not require an employer to hire an individual with a criminal background in the event there is no direct and adverse relationship between the job and the conviction. In contrast, similar laws in New York, Minnesota, and Hawaii expressly ban rejecting an applicant unless the conviction relates to the job. The court also said that the Fair Chance Act did not prohibit consideration of convictions seven or more years old. The court said the seven-year rule applies only to “bright-line” hiring policies that disproportionately affect protected groups, not to individual cases like this.
Finally, the court said that cutting the five-day response period short is a violation of the Fair Chance Act, but the applicant is not entitled to damages unless the violation actually hurt him. Under general California law, a plaintiff must show the violation caused harm, and unlike some other laws, the Fair Chance Act doesn’t provide automatic “statutory damages” for a violation. Here, the jury found his criminal history was not a substantial factor in the decision and that UCLA would have made the same decision even if he’d had the full five days.
Action Items
- Review background check procedures for compliance with the Fair Chance Act.
- Accurately document the reason for rescinding an offer of employment.
- Have appropriate personnel trained on background screening procedures.
California: Supervisors Cannot Be Personally Sued for Retaliation Under Labor Code Section 1102.5
On September 28, 2026, in Chaudhry v. State of California, the California Court of Appeal said that supervisors cannot be sued personally for retaliation under Labor Code Section 1102.5, California’s general whistleblower law. Here, a dental assistant at a prison medical facility filed several workplace safety complaints with Cal/OSHA. She says the facility retaliated with unfair criticism, a one-month unpaid suspension, a firing in 2020, and a second firing in 2022. She sued the employer and three supervisors under California’s general whistleblower law (Labor Code section 1102.5) and the California Whistleblower Protection Act. In rejecting the claims against the individual supervisors, the court reasoned that making supervisors personally liable would add little for employees, would make managers afraid to make ordinary personnel decisions, and would set supervisors against their employers. It also noted that the Legislature never said it meant to hold supervisors personally liable.
California: Proposed Updates to Pregnancy Accommodation and Leave Rules
On October 19, 2026, the California Civil Rights Council released proposed regulations that would expand pregnancy-related accommodation and leave protections and align state rules with the federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. The proposal would expressly cover past, potential, and intended pregnancy, infertility and fertility treatment, and additional related conditions, including postpartum anxiety and psychosis, pregnancy loss, abortion, and lactation conditions. Accommodation options would include remote work, worksite changes, pain-reducing modifications, and temporary suspension of essential job functions. Employers would be required to respond to accommodation requests “as soon as practicable” through an informal, good-faith interactive process. The proposal would also clarify that intermittent pregnancy disability leave may be used for childbirth and related medical conditions and eliminate the general requirement that bonding leave be taken in two-week increments. The proposal is not final and does not change current obligations. Employers should monitor the rulemaking process and assess how the proposed changes could affect accommodation procedures and leave policies.
California: Headless PAGA Claims Permitted Under Post-2024 Law
On October 23, 2026, in Castillo v. Belkorp AG, LLC, the California Court of Appeal said that an aggrieved employee may bring a Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) action that consists only of nonindividual (“headless”) PAGA claims under the post-July 1, 2024 version of PAGA, without also bringing individual claims. There is a split of authority on whether headless PAGA claims are permitted under the pre-July 1, 2024 version of PAGA; this ruling expands the argument post-amendment. The ruling was based largely on statutory interpretation, case precedent, and the fact that the legislature has not otherwise amended the law to prohibit headless PAGA claims despite the opportunity. This case further contributes to the overall split in authority on PAGA generally and increases the likelihood of California Supreme Court intervention on the topic.
San Mateo County, CA: Permit Required for Certain Workplace Robots
Effective October 29, 2026, a new ordinance in unincorporated San Mateo County will require certain public-facing businesses to obtain an annually renewable County permit before operating certain fully or partially autonomous robots. Covered robots include those that use cameras or sensors, operate at least partly without human control in areas accessible to workers or the public, and use rechargeable lithium-ion batteries. Stationary self-checkout kiosks and permanently fixed-path equipment are excluded. Permit applications must address applicable safety, accessibility, privacy, and food-safety requirements and include an Economic Impact Assessment and Workforce Mitigation Plan. If deployment of a covered robot displaces workers, the mitigation plan must provide for at least one of three options: (1) redeployment to an equivalent position at equal or greater compensation; (2) transition assistance consisting of at least 60 days’ advance written notice and four weeks of standard pay as severance; or (3) payment of a County Automation Impact Fee. Businesses must also plan for at least one trained human supervisor to remain physically present whenever covered robots operate in customer- or public-facing areas and maintain a public complaint log for each robot. Affected employers should confirm location and equipment coverage, address permitting before deployment, and review workforce, safety, and privacy practices. Violations may result in fines and permit suspension or revocation.
California: Public Works Employers Barred from Using Evidence for Procedural Violations
As of January 1, 2027, SB 1316 will prohibit public works contractors from being able to rely on certain payroll, time, and employment records to defend themselves if those records are not timely produced upon request. Specifically, this penalty occurs when the Labor Commissioner requests records that a contractor or subcontractor is legally required to maintain, and the employer fails to produce them within the time stated in the written request, and no statutory exception otherwise applies. Employers that do not timely produce required documents may be precluded from using them.
California: Mid-Project Prevailing Wage Changes for Large Public Works Contracts
Effective July 1, 2027, AB 1198 will require updated prevailing wage determinations to apply during performance of covered California public works contracts with an awarded prime contract value of $35 million or more. Currently, rates generally remain tied to those in effect at bid, subject to predetermined increases. The new requirements will also apply to subcontractors on covered projects regardless of their subcontract’s value, but qualifying affordable housing developments are exempt. The law does not specify who bears the cost of mid-project increases, so contractors should review bid pricing and contract terms in preparation.
Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase
