New Jersey
New Jersey: Court Upholds Reinstatement of Employee Discharged After Positive Cannabis Test
|
APPLIES TO All Employers with Employees in NJ |
EFFECTIVE SEP 21, 2026 |
QUESTIONS? Contact HR On-Call |
Quick Look
|
Discussion
On September 21, 2026, in County Concrete Corporation v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters Local 863, the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey upheld an arbitrator’s award reinstating an employee who was discharged after testing positive for cannabis. As the basis for termination, the employer relied on a reported marijuana odor and the employee’s second positive test, but the arbitrator found that the employer had not established workplace cannabis use, possession, or impairment. The court declined to overturn that determination under the deferential standard applicable to labor arbitration awards.
New Jersey’s Cannabis Regulatory, Enforcement Assistance, and Marketplace Modernization Act (CREAMMA) prohibits employers from taking adverse employment action solely because an employee tests positive for cannabinoid metabolites. The law permits testing in circumstances including reasonable suspicion of on-duty cannabis use, observable signs of intoxication, and certain work-related accidents. The distinction matters because a positive test does not, by itself, establish that an employee used cannabis at work or was impaired while working.
In this case, during a lunch break, the employee in question drove his personal vehicle past a supervisor and coworker on company property. Both reported detecting a strong marijuana odor from the vehicle. The employer directed the employee to undergo testing, which returned a positive result. Because the employee had previously tested positive, the company terminated him under its two-strike policy.
The employee’s union challenged the termination through arbitration. The arbitrator ordered reinstatement with full back pay, seniority, and benefits, finding insufficient evidence that the employee used or possessed cannabis at work or was impaired. The employer then asked the federal court to vacate the award, arguing that the arbitrator disregarded CREAMMA and exceeded her authority under the collective bargaining agreement.
The court explained that judicial review of labor arbitration awards is limited. A court does not simply reconsider the underlying dispute or substitute its judgment for the arbitrator’s, even when an employer alleges errors of law or fact. Within this framework, the court found that the arbitrator had not manifestly disregarded CREAMMA or exceeded her contractual authority.
The court explained that marijuana odor, standing alone, showed only that cannabis may have been present at some point, not that the employee used it while performing his duties or was impaired on company property. Additionally, the court emphasized the absence of other evidence, finding that there was no testimony that the employee slurred his speech, had glassy eyes, performed poorly, or otherwise appeared impaired. The employer also allowed him to finish his shift without any reported impairment and did not document the reported odor until more than a week later. These facts departed from nonbinding best practices issued by the New Jersey Cannabis Regulatory Commission, which the arbitrator considered when evaluating the evidence.
The decision does not establish that every cannabis-related termination requires the same evidence or that the Commission’s best practices are independently binding requirements. It does illustrate the risk of relying on a positive test and odor without additional evidence connecting the concern to workplace conduct. Importantly, a policy allowing termination after a specified number of positive tests does not eliminate the need to comply with CREAMMA.
Action Items
- Review cannabis testing and disciplinary policies, including automatic termination provisions, for compliance.
- Establish procedures for promptly documenting specific observations supporting suspected on-duty cannabis use or impairment.
- Have appropriate personnel trained on drug testing requirements.
- Consult with legal counsel before taking adverse action as the result of a positive employee test.
New Jersey: Proposal to Drop Pay Range Cap
On October 19, 2026, the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development (NJDOL) proposed revising its still-pending September 2025 pay transparency regulations to remove a numerical cap on posted pay ranges. The original proposal would have limited the difference between a range’s maximum and minimum to 60 percent of the minimum. The October notice proposes deleting that provision, including its calculation method and exceptions, while leaving the remaining proposed requirements unchanged. Neither the original regulations nor the proposed revision has been finalized, so the cap is not an existing obligation. New Jersey’s pay transparency statute, effective June 1, 2025, remains in effect, including pay and benefits disclosures for covered postings and reasonable efforts to notify affected employees of promotional opportunities. Employers should continue complying with the statute and monitor the rulemaking for final requirements and an effective date. Written comments on the proposed revision are due December 18, 2026.
Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide general information and guidance concerning employment-related issues. It is presented with the understanding that ManagEase is not engaged in rendering any legal opinions. If a legal opinion is needed, please contact the services of your own legal adviser. © 2026 ManagEase
